Medial Collateral Ligament Injuries

The medial collateral ligament is one of four major ligaments of the knee. The medial collateral ligament extends from the medial epicondyle of the femur to below the medial condyle of the tibia. The MCL is a static stabilizer composed of superficial (primary) and deep (secondary) portions that are restraints to valgus stress. The superficial MCL is the primary restraint to valgus stress.  The proximal attachment is located on the posterior aspect of the medial femoral condyle. The distal attachment is located at the metaphyseal region of the tibia, about 5cm distal to the joint, lying beneath the pes anserinus.   The Deep MCL assists as a secondary restraint to valgus stress. The Deep MCL inserts directly into the edge of the tibial plateau and meniscus. It may be separated from the superficial layer by a bursa. The joined tendons of the Sartorius, gracilis, and semitendinosus muscles cross on top of the lower part of the MCL. The pes anserine bursa is located anterior to the insertion of the medial collateral ligament into the tibia. The MCL’s primary function is to be a restraint to valgus stress. The MCL is the most commonly injured ligament of the knee. The typical mechanism of injury of the MCL is due to a valgus and external rotation force. A direct blow to the knee usually causes a complete rupture of the MCL. Rupture may occur proximally or distally. Tears of the proximal MCL have a greater healing rate; however, tears of the distal MCL may not heal well (similar to a Stener lesion of the thumb). Injury to the ACL comprise up to 95% of associated injuries. Rupture of the ACL causes anterolateral rotatory instability. The majority of MCL injuries that are associated with ACL injuries are Grade III complete ruptures, no end point with valgus stress at 30° and 0° of knee flexion. Up to 5% of isolated MCL injuries are associated with meniscal tears. Not a common injury. MCL sprains are classified into three different grades. Grade I injuries are a sprain or stretching injury. Grade II injuries consist of a partial tear of the MCL. Grade III tears are a complete tear of the ligament with no end point with valgus stress at 30° of knee flexion.

A medial collateral ligament injury will typically create a “popping” sensation. Pain and tenderness is usually found higher than the joint line. During the physical examination, tenderness will be discovered along the medial aspect of the knee. A positive valgus stress test at 30° of knee flexion indicates injury to the superficial MCL. Opening around 1 cm indicates a Grade III complete tear of the MCL. A positive valgus stress test at 0° of knee extension indicates posteromedial capsule or cruciate ligament injury in addition to MCL injury (combined injury). The physician should always evaluate for other injuries to the ACL, PCL, or medial meniscal tear.  Radiographs are usually normal; however, they may show calcification at the medial femoral site (Pellegrini-Stieda Syndrome). Calcification due to chronic MCL deficiency at the medial femoral insertion site. A pediatric patient with a knee injury and a suspected salter fracture should have stress view x-rays performed to rule out a growth plate injury. Growth plates are weaker than ligaments and it may be more beneficial to have an MRI performed rather than stress view x-rays. An MRI is the study of choice as it identifies the location and extent of the MCL injury.

Treatment typically consists of NSAIDs, rest, and therapy. A minor sprain of the MCL will require therapy with a return to play in about a week. A brace may be used if the injury is classified as a Grade II and they will return to play in about 2-4 weeks. With Grade III injuries, there will be a return to play in about 6-8 weeks. Surgery is performed in Grade III injuries with a multiple ligament injury, especially with distal avulsion fractures. If there is chronic instability with opening in full extension, a reconstruction should be performed. An additional arthroscopy may be needed to rule out associated injuries. In combined MCL and ACL injuries, usually surgery for the ACL is delayed until the MCL heals (up to eight weeks) and then an ACL brace should be used. Complications consist of stiffness and loss of motion. Laxity is associated with distal MCL injuries. Functional bracing may reduce an MCL injury in football players, particularly with interior linemen.

Nabil Ebraheim, MD

You Might Also Enjoy...

Motions of the Thumb

The motions of the thumb are complex and are often difficult to visualize, as multiple joints and planes are involved. The motions are crucial to the overall function of the hand, with amputation of the thumb resulting in 40% impairment.

Subscapularis Muscle Tear

The subscapularis muscle is a large muscle that originates on the anterior surface of the scapula and lies in front of the shoulder. The subscapularis muscle tendon inserts into the lesser tuberosity of the humerus.

Knee Dislocations

Dislocation of the knee is a serious problem. It should be recognized and managed appropriately early.